Quiz Entry - updated: 2026.10.15
What are the main advantages and disadvantages of video surveillance in public space?
Pros: better public safety, lower crime, catching criminals, collecting evidence, everyday convenience. Cons: misuse, threats to privacy, doubtful effectiveness, high costs.
| Advantages | Example | Disadvantages | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| Improve public safety | Monitoring natural hazards | Misuse | Blackmail |
| Lower crime rates | Surveillance of sales floors | Threat to privacy | Profiling |
| Catch criminals | Monitoring people at airports | Doubtful effectiveness | Cameras can signal that a target is worth attacking |
| Collect and provide evidence | Documenting hooliganism | High costs | Staff-intensive review of footage |
| Everyday convenience | Traffic monitoring to prevent jams |
The utilitarian case rests on the left column. The deontological objection lives in the right column's privacy and misuse rows. And "doubtful effectiveness" challenges the utilitarian case on its own terms.
Go deeper:
Wikipedia: Closed-circuit television — includes research on how effective CCTV is against crime.