Question
Where does the word "critique" come from, and why does that origin contradict everyday use of the word?
Answer
It comes from the ancient Greek verb "krínein" (to separate, judge, decide) — so "critique" originally means the art of judging and distinguishing well, not the act of badmouthing something.
In everyday speech "to criticise" carries a negative charge: to find fault, to complain. Budelacci argues that this is a corruption of the term. The Greek krínein means to sift — to separate the true from the false, the important from the unimportant, the worthwhile from the worthless. So critical thinking is not a sour disposition that rejects things; it is a disciplined skill of good judgement: deciding whether a statement is true or false, relevant or trivial, worth pursuing or worth avoiding.
Tip: The same root sits inside "criterion" and "to discern" — all about distinguishing, not disparaging. If your "critique" only tears down and never sorts true from false, it isn't critique in this sense.
Go deeper:
Wikipedia — Critical thinking — the discipline this word names: analysing evidence and arguments to reach sound judgements.
Note saved — thanks!
Question
What is the opposite of critical thinking, in this account?
Answer
Dogmatic and ideological thinking — holding beliefs as fixed and beyond questioning.
Critical thinking is defined partly by its contrast. Its opposite is not "positive" or "trusting" thinking; it is dogmatism (treating a doctrine as settled truth no evidence could revise) and ideology (a closed system of belief that explains everything in advance). Both share one feature: they place certain claims outside the reach of examination. Critical thinking, by contrast, keeps claims open to being tested, and — crucially — a critical thinker can change their mind when the reasons demand it. That willingness to revise is intellectual openness, and it is exactly what dogma forbids.
Go deeper:
Wikipedia — Dogma — a belief held "without the possibility of reform."
Wikipedia — Ideology — a coherent belief-system that interprets the world in advance.
Note saved — thanks!